AS Roma offers Chelsea €5M loan for Alejandro Garnacho with buy option

AS Roma has lobbed an opening offer at Chelsea for Argentine winger Alejandro Garnacho, proposing a €5 million loan fee paired with a €35 million option to buy. Chelsea, meanwhile, wants roughly €50 million in a straight sale. The gap between those two positions is the kind of chasm that either produces weeks of tedious negotiation or kills a deal entirely.

The deal structure, decoded

Roma’s proposal follows what insiders are calling a “Malen-style” arrangement, referencing a previous transfer for Dutch forward Donyell Malen that used a similar framework. The structure works like this: Roma would pay €5 million upfront just to borrow Garnacho for a season. The €35 million buy option could become mandatory if certain conditions are met, likely tied to a set number of appearances or specific performance benchmarks.

The total potential value of Roma’s offer, €40 million when you combine the loan fee and the buy option, still sits €10 million below Chelsea’s valuation. What makes this particularly interesting from a financial structuring perspective is the conditional trigger mechanism. If the buy option becomes obligatory after, say, 25 league appearances, it functions almost identically to a call option in traditional finance. Roma gets downside protection (if Garnacho flops, they walk away having paid only €5 million), while Chelsea faces the risk of losing a player at below-market value if he performs well.

Why Garnacho wants Rome

The player himself reportedly favors the move, drawn by the prospect of playing alongside Roma captain Paulo Dybala. Both are Argentine internationals, and the lure of building a South American creative partnership in Serie A appears to be a significant motivating factor for Garnacho.

Chelsea’s preference for a permanent sale makes financial sense given their broader squad management strategy. Loan deals with conditional purchase options introduce uncertainty into financial planning, something that matters when you’re trying to balance the books under UEFA’s financial sustainability regulations.

The bigger picture for football finance

The €10 million gap between Roma’s total package and Chelsea’s asking price will likely be the central negotiation battleground in the coming days. One common resolution in these situations involves adjusting the conditions that make the buy option mandatory, making the trigger easier to hit so that the option is effectively guaranteed to convert into a permanent transfer. If Roma agrees to a lower appearance threshold or broader performance criteria, Chelsea might accept the loan structure knowing the purchase is all but certain.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.