CFTC seeks to vacate $5 million penalty against Gemini Trust Company

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is asking a federal judge to undo a $5 million penalty it already collected from Gemini Trust Company, calling the entire enforcement action a product of flawed evidence and questionable tactics from the Biden era.

The CFTC and Gemini jointly filed a motion on May 27 in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York to vacate key provisions of a consent order that was entered just last year, in January 2025.

What the CFTC found when it looked in the mirror

The CFTC originally filed its complaint against Gemini on June 2, 2022, alleging the crypto exchange made misleading statements to the agency back in 2017. Those alleged misstatements related to information Gemini provided while seeking approval for a Bitcoin futures product.

The January 2025 consent order resolved that complaint. Gemini paid the $5 million civil monetary penalty without admitting the CFTC’s findings, and a permanent injunction was put in place.

The CFTC conducted a detailed reassessment of its enforcement approach and concluded that the original complaint against Gemini would not have been brought under the agency’s current standards.

The review identified specific, material problems with how the case was built. The agency found it had relied on an untrustworthy whistleblower account as a foundation for its complaint. It also flagged weaknesses in the underlying evidence against Gemini.

The review raised concerns about internal deliberative process privilege issues and personnel decisions that were perceived as attempts to pressure the company into settling.

The CFTC described Gemini as more of a victim in the broader situation than a perpetrator, yet the agency pursued the exchange instead of the alleged bad actors.

A broader shift in enforcement philosophy

During the Biden administration, the CFTC and SEC pursued an aggressive enforcement-first strategy against crypto companies. Gemini, founded by Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss and operating as a New York trust company and digital asset exchange, was one of many firms caught in that dragnet.

The current administration has taken a different view. Agencies are now reassessing prior enforcement actions and asking whether the cases were justified on the merits or were products of an overzealous regulatory posture.

What this means for investors

For Gemini specifically, the practical impact is more symbolic than financial. The $5 million penalty has already been paid and satisfied. What the exchange stands to gain is the removal of the permanent injunction and the regulatory stigma associated with a CFTC enforcement action.

The other thing to watch is whether this motion actually succeeds. The CFTC and Gemini filed jointly, which means there’s no adversarial opposition to the request. But the court still has to approve the vacatur.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.