US stocks set for higher open as payrolls data eases rate-hike bets

The US labor market handed Wall Street an unexpected gift on Thursday morning. July nonfarm payrolls fell by 23,000 jobs, a result that landed nowhere near economist forecasts calling for a gain of somewhere between 80,000 and 95,000. Markets loved it.

S&P 500 futures climbed roughly 0.53% following the release. Nasdaq 100 futures jumped 1.16%, and Dow E-minis added 0.31%. The logic is counterintuitive but well-established by now: bad news for workers can be good news for stocks, because softer labor data reduces the pressure on the Federal Reserve to keep tightening monetary policy.

What the numbers actually said

The headline payroll figure was striking enough on its own, but the revisions made it sharper. June’s initial reading of 57,000 jobs added was revised down to just 20,000, suggesting the labor market had been cooling faster than official data had indicated.

The unemployment rate did edge lower, falling to 4.1% from 4.2% in June. That sounds like a contradiction, but it isn’t entirely. The decline in the participation rate, meaning fewer people are actively looking for work, can mechanically push the unemployment rate down even as overall hiring slows. Economists sometimes describe this labor market dynamic as “slow hire, slow fire,” a state where companies are neither aggressively adding staff nor laying workers off in large numbers.

July marked the first outright negative payroll reading in recent months, which means this report carries more weight than a simple miss would.

The Federal Reserve’s policy rate currently sits in the 3.50% to 3.75% range. Coming into this report, the market was already uncertain about the Fed’s next move. Three Fed officials dissented at the most recent meeting in favor of a rate hike, which signals internal disagreement about the right path forward.

Why markets are reading this as a green light

The Nasdaq’s outperformance relative to the Dow is also telling. Tech stocks are particularly sensitive to interest rate expectations because so much of their valuation rests on earnings projected far into the future. Lower rates make those distant earnings worth more in today’s dollars. A 1.16% move in Nasdaq 100 futures versus a 0.31% move in Dow E-minis is a textbook expression of that dynamic.

The Fed’s tightrope gets narrower

Fed Chair Jerome Powell has consistently emphasized that policy decisions will be data-dependent. A payroll decline of 23,000, against expectations of a gain nearly four times that magnitude, is not a rounding error.

The three dissenting officials who wanted a rate hike at the last meeting will find their case considerably more difficult to make after this release. Hiking into a labor market that just printed negative job growth requires a level of inflation urgency that the current data does not obviously support.

The Fed’s internal disagreement, visible through those three dissenting votes, means the outcome is genuinely uncertain rather than a foregone conclusion.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.