Tottenham struggles with player fitness after World Cup as Newcastle test looms

Roberto De Zerbi is not a manager who sugarcoats things. After Tottenham’s 3-0 defeat at Brentford on Saturday, he publicly singled out three of his own new signings for being physically below the required standard. Jan Paul van Hecke, Marcos Senesi, and Sandro Tonali were all given what you might charitably call constructive feedback, and what you might more accurately call a very public dressing down.

The timing is particularly awkward. Tottenham had just brushed aside Charlton 3-0 in what looked like a comfortable return to action. That result apparently masked deeper problems lurking beneath the surface, problems that a side like Brentford was more than capable of exposing.

The World Cup hangover is real

The root cause isn’t exactly mysterious. The 2026 FIFA World Cup wrapped up recently, and players who participated in the tournament are still working their way back to peak condition. Recovery timelines are compressed, pre-season preparation gets truncated, and managers are left trying to field competitive squads with players running on fumes.

De Zerbi made clear that none of this caught him off guard. He knew the condition of his new arrivals before the Brentford match. The coaching staff had anticipated the gap between where these players were physically and where they needed to be.

Charlton flattery, Brentford reality

The contrast between the two recent results tells the whole story. Against Charlton, Tottenham’s physical shortcomings were invisible. The 3-0 scoreline looked convincing on paper. It was, in retrospect, a mirage.

Brentford presented the kind of relentless pressing and physical intensity that the Premier League serves up as standard. Tottenham wilted. The 3-0 defeat wasn’t a case of bad luck or marginal decisions going the wrong way. It was a team that couldn’t sustain the level of effort required across 90 minutes at the top level.

For Tottenham, the issue is compounded by the fact that the affected players are new signings. They’re not just physically behind. They’re also still integrating into a new system, learning new teammates’ tendencies, and adapting to a new manager’s tactical demands.

Newcastle won’t be as forgiving

If Brentford exposed the cracks, Newcastle United could blow them wide open. The upcoming Premier League fixture against Newcastle is considered significantly more challenging, and De Zerbi faces an uncomfortable calculation: does he continue to play the unfit new signings, hoping match minutes accelerate their conditioning, even at the risk of another heavy defeat? Or does he bench expensive acquisitions in favor of players who are further along in their preparation?

De Zerbi clearly sees the problem with eyes wide open. He’s not pretending things are fine or hiding behind excuses. His willingness to name names publicly suggests a manager who wants accountability established early, even if it makes for uncomfortable headlines.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.