MCAP $2.18T ▼ 3.13% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:05 UTC 24H VOL $76.7B Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:05 UTC BTC.D 59.2% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:05 UTC FEAR & GREED 12 Extreme Fear Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 00:00 UTC BTC FEE 1 sat/vB Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:55 UTC BTC $64,821 ▲ 0.47% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC EQQQQ $655.75 Last updated 8 Nov 2026, 12:03 UTC ETH $1,817 ▲ 0.39% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC MGLOEURO $111,813 ▼ 0.36% Last updated 27 Oct 2026, 02:04 UTC USDT $0.9992 ▼ 0.01% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC BNB $593.15 ▲ 0.42% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC USDC $0.9996 ▼ 0.00% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC XRP $0.9683 ▲ 1.19% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC SOL $73.31 ▲ 2.54% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC TRX $0.3055 ▲ 0.23% Last updated 17 Nov 2026, 11:52 UTC

Regulation · Explained

Judge acquits MIT brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case

A Manhattan federal judge found prosecutors did not prove wire fraud, closing the criminal case without a retrial.

CoinDesk CC AI Desk
· 3 min read
✓ 4 SOURCES CHECKED
Judge acquits MIT brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case
Image: Decrypt

Key takeaways

  1. Acquittal. Judge Jessica Clarke granted judgment of acquittal on wire fraud and conspiracy counts, and the money-laundering conspiracy charge failed with them.
  2. No retrial. The decision follows a November 2025 mistrial and closes the prosecution without a second trial.
  3. Rationale. Clarke said Ethereum is a trustless, adversarial environment without terms of use, and conduct that may have frustrated MEV-Boost's spirit did not amount to fraud.

What happened

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers charged over an Ethereum trading exploit, ending the criminal prosecution without a second trial. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted their motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, according to her ruling. The brothers had faced wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Decrypt and Cointelegraph reported the ruling.

Prosecutors tied the case to an April 2023 operation aimed at sandwich bots, automated traders that seek profit from maximal extractable value by placing trades around other users' transactions. The ruling described bait transactions intended to draw specific bots, followed by use of a relay code flaw that let the brothers view the bots' bundled trades before committing a block. They then replaced the bait trades with transactions that sold the tokens, leaving the bots with about $25 million in losses in roughly 12 seconds.

Authorities arrested the pair in May 2024. At trial, an insider testified about the alleged planning, and the defense had earlier tried to keep evidence of the brothers' Google searches out of the case. Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors deadlocked. Her acquittal ruling described the prosecution as a first of its kind, a phrase the government also used in the indictment.

$2.5K$1.8K18 Oct17 Nov

First $2.4KLatest $1.8K-24.6% over the period

Points are daily observations, not closing prices.

Why it matters

The case was closely watched across the crypto industry because it tested whether wire fraud law could reach conduct inside an open blockchain network. Clarke's decision turned on a narrow element: to convict, prosecutors had to show the brothers made a material misrepresentation, and she found that none of the government's theories did. The money-laundering conspiracy charge depended on the fraud proceeds, so it failed as well.

Clarke characterized Ethereum as a trustless and highly adversarial setting without terms of use. She said the scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost, which lets validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized builders, but that was not enough for fraud. In a footnote, she said the prosecution raised serious due process concerns, though she did not decide that issue.

Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of Coin Center, called the acquittal excellent news, according to Cointelegraph. He said the government's honest-validator theory risked letting prosecutors apply their own standards of conduct to Ethereum validators through wire fraud. Participants in open networks, he added, would otherwise have to wonder whether their behavior might later be declared dishonest in court.

What the data shows

Key figures in the case include about $25 million in losses, roughly 12 seconds of execution, an April 2023 exploit, a May 2024 arrest and a November 2025 mistrial. The indictment charged wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Clarke's Monday ruling granted judgment of acquittal on those charges and closed the case without another trial.

Background

The dispute had already gone through a full trial before the acquittal. Authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024 and said they had spent months planning the attack and taken steps to conceal the proceeds. Jurors later deadlocked, prompting Clarke to declare a mistrial in November 2025. The ruling also cited a 2025 decision involving Avraham Eisenberg, a Mango Markets trader, in which a judge found insufficient evidence of false representations.

What to watch

The ruling does not settle whether the brothers' conduct was ethical or whether it violated other laws. Clarke also declined to rule on the due process question she flagged. Those limits mean the decision closes this prosecution but leaves broader questions about how fraud statutes apply to MEV and other open-network strategies. The reports do not indicate whether prosecutors will appeal.

Questions readers ask

What does the acquittal mean?

It ends the criminal case against Anton and James Peraire-Bueno without a retrial. The judge found prosecutors did not prove the material misrepresentation needed for wire fraud, and the money-laundering conspiracy charge fell with the fraud counts.

Why did the judge rule this way?

Clarke described Ethereum as a trustless, adversarial environment with no terms of use. She found that conduct possibly at odds with the spirit of MEV-Boost did not amount to fraud under the government's theories.

Does the ruling say the conduct was ethical?

No. The judge said the question was not whether the brothers' actions were right, moral or a violation of uncharged crimes. She also declined to rule on due process concerns raised by the prosecution.

Sources · 4 publishers

  1. The Block TIER 1 FIRST REPORT
    Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of wire fraud in $25 million Ethereum MEV case
  2. Decrypt TIER 1
    Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case, Ending Prosecution
  3. Cointelegraph TIER 1
    US judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrial
  4. Unchained TIER 1
    Judge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ in $25 Million Ethereum Case, Finding No Misrepresentation