Ethereum · Explained
Buterin urges Canadians to press senators over Bill C-22 encryption
Ethereum's co-founder compared the lawful access bill to the EU's Chat Control debate and asked Canadians to back encryption without backdoors.
Key takeaways
- Public push. Buterin asked Canadians to lobby senators directly and linked to an October 8 Mozilla paper on the bill's encryption effects.
- Still in committee. The bill passed the Commons on June 18 and cleared Senate second reading on October 22 before going to the national security committee.
- Crypto scope unclear. Exchanges, wallets and self-custody apps are not listed, and the core-provider schedule is left blank for future regulations.
What happened
Vitalik Buterin used a November 17 post on X to urge Canadians to contact their senators about Bill C-22, the federal lawful access legislation, casting it as a Canadian version of the European Union's encryption fight. The Ethereum co-founder wrote that the country is going through "its own version of the Chat Control mess" with the bill.
In the same post he asked Canadians to support end-to-end encryption that is "backdoor-free, no asterisks," calling such protection important to a secure, free and open society. He also urged governments to keep backdoors and mass data collection to a minimum as artificial intelligence changes the cybersecurity landscape, and pointed readers to an October 8 Mozilla paper on the bill's effect on encryption.
Formally known as the Lawful Access Act, 2026, the bill is not yet law. The House of Commons passed it on June 18, and the Senate approved second reading on October 22 before referring it to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs. That committee heard from Meta, Signal, privacy advocates and legal experts at a November 16 hearing, and report stage, third reading and royal assent all remain outstanding.
Part 2 of the proposal would let the government require providers to develop and maintain technical capabilities for lawful access. The order itself would not hand over data; Ottawa says investigators would still need legal authorization to obtain personal information and that the bill grants no direct access to company systems.
First $2.4KLatest $1.8K-25.1% over the period
Points are daily observations, not closing prices.
Why it matters
For crypto users, the practical question is scope. The bill defines electronic service providers broadly, covering organizations that create, store, process, transmit, receive or make electronic information available to people in Canada, or that conduct business there. Crypto exchanges, wallet providers and self-custody apps are not named. A centralized exchange or hosted wallet serving Canadians could fall inside the definition if it stores account details or processes customer transactions, while the text does not require self-custody developers to hold users' private keys. Whether a given wallet developer or privacy tool is captured would depend on how the service operates.
What the data shows
The House-passed version includes a decryption carve-out: a provider cannot be forced to decrypt information a customer encrypted, or to ensure authorities can decrypt it, unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the material needed to unlock it. Providers also would not have to meet technical obligations that introduce a systemic vulnerability or prevent them from fixing one, though that definition excludes risks tied only to people covered by a warrant or other legal authority. The core-provider schedule is left blank for future regulations; those providers could be required to retain specified metadata, such as the date, time, duration, origin and destination of an exchange, for up to six months. Message content, web-browsing history and social media activity are excluded. The public safety minister could issue orders to any electronic service provider, inside or outside the core category, lasting up to two years and requiring Intelligence Commissioner approval, with providers given a chance to make representations.
Background
Mozilla argued in its October paper that there is no safe way to create exceptional access to encrypted data usable only by intended actors, warning that companies could be required to build capabilities that bypass existing protections or to supply data before encryption. Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne told senators on November 2 that he welcomed amendments precluding requirements to decrypt end-to-end encrypted information, but sought clearer limits on subscriber information and a necessity-and-proportionality test. The UN Human Rights Office said in November 3 comments that the bill threatens to undermine end-to-end encryption and recommended an explicit safeguard provision, which the Canadian Civil Liberties Association has cited in its call for amendments. The EU comparison has limits: the bloc's long-term child sexual abuse proposal concerns detecting and reporting abuse material, including disputed scanning of private communications, and talks on detection remain unresolved. A separate temporary EU measure allowing voluntary detection runs until April 3, 2028 and excludes end-to-end encrypted communications, according to the Council of the EU.
What is still unclear
Two gaps drive much of the uncertainty. The core-provider list is empty in the House-passed text, leaving those categories to regulations that have not been published, and the broad provider definition means coverage of crypto services turns on individual product design rather than an explicit listing.
What to watch
Attention now shifts to the Senate committee, which must report the bill before report stage, third reading and royal assent. How drafters fill the core-provider schedule, and whether amendments sharpen the encryption protections, will determine which crypto businesses face retention and technical obligations.
Questions readers ask
What is Bill C-22?
It is the Lawful Access Act, 2026. It has passed the House of Commons and is being studied by a Senate committee, with report stage, third reading and royal assent still to come.
Does the bill require providers to break encryption?
The House-passed text says a provider cannot be forced to decrypt customer-encrypted information, or ensure authorities can decrypt it, unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the key material.
Are crypto exchanges covered?
They are not named. A centralized exchange or hosted wallet serving Canadians could qualify if it stores account details or processes transactions, and the core-provider categories are left to future regulations.