MCAP $2.18T ▼ 3.66% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:00 UTC 24H VOL $69.5B Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:00 UTC BTC.D 58.1% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:00 UTC FEAR & GREED 11 Extreme Fear Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 00:00 UTC BTC FEE 4 sat/vB Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:50 UTC BTC $62,391 ▼ 2.17% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC EQQQQ $655.75 Last updated 8 Nov 2026, 12:03 UTC ETH $1,736 ▼ 2.35% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC MGLOEURO $111,813 ▼ 0.36% Last updated 27 Oct 2026, 02:04 UTC USDT $0.9992 ▼ 0.01% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC BNB $577.14 ▼ 1.26% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC USDC $0.9996 ▼ 0.01% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC XRP $0.9653 ▲ 0.87% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC SOL $72.43 ▲ 0.36% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC TRX $0.3087 ▲ 0.41% Last updated 18 Nov 2026, 16:46 UTC

Hacks & Security · Explained

US judge acquits brothers in $25m Ethereum MEV case

Judge Jessica Clarke ruled prosecutors did not prove the material misrepresentation required for wire fraud in the first criminal MEV prosecution.

CoinDesk CC AI Desk
· 3 min read
✓ 2 SOURCES CHECKED
US judge acquits brothers in $25m Ethereum MEV case
Image: Coinpedia

Key takeaways

  1. Fraud element missing. Judge Clarke held that neither the bait transactions nor the falsified block-header fields amounted to a material misrepresentation on which another party relied.
  2. Mistrial preceded acquittal. The brothers were indicted in May 2024, and their first trial ended without a verdict in November 2025 before the November 16 ruling closed the case.
  3. Narrow holding. The decision addresses the specific fraud charges rather than declaring every form of MEV extraction lawful.

What happened

A federal judge in the United States has cleared two MIT-educated brothers, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, who were accused of taking roughly $25 million from automated Ethereum trading bots, ending the government's first criminal prosecution built around a maximal extractable value (MEV) exploit. US District Judge Jessica Clarke issued the ruling on November 16, 2026, and directed the court clerk to close the case.

Clarke concluded that prosecutors had not established the material misrepresentation that wire fraud requires. The acquittal also covered conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, and the case will not return to trial.

The alleged operation took place in April 2023. According to the court's account, the brothers set out eight bait transactions intended to attract sandwich-trading bots, which watch Ethereum's public transaction queue, known as the mempool, for pending orders they can trade around. When their validator was chosen to process a block, it signed a block header containing two fields set to zero, describing a block that could not have been valid. The Ultrasound relay did not verify those fields and released the transactions inside anyway.

The brothers then assembled their own block, preserving the bots' purchases while replacing the bait trades with sales that drove prices lower. The bots lost approximately $25 million in about 12 seconds, while the brothers' validator absorbed a penalty of around 1 ETH.

$2.5K$1.8K19 Oct18 Nov

First $2.4KLatest $1.8K-26.7% over the period

Points are daily observations, not closing prices.

Why it matters

The ruling gives courts and market participants a reference point for where aggressive on-chain tactics stop and criminal fraud begins. Clarke described Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," underscoring how hard it is to apply conventional fraud principles to infrastructure designed without stated rules. She rejected the argument that posting transactions to the public mempool amounts to an implicit promise that they will be processed in a particular order or alongside other orders, noting the mempool guarantees no such sequencing.

On the disputed header fields, the judge found that the relay never checked the values, so the information did not shape its behavior and could not support the fraud theory. She acknowledged that the brothers concealed their intentions and may have acted against the spirit of the relay software's design, but said conduct that is improper or objectionable does not become criminal simply because prosecutors charge it. The decision settles the specific allegations rather than establishing that all MEV strategies are permitted, and it leaves open questions about sandwich attacks and the duties of infrastructure operators.

What the data shows

Court proceedings put the losses suffered by the targeted bots at approximately $25 million, incurred within roughly 12 seconds. The bait consisted of eight transactions. The brothers' validator was penalized about 1 ETH. On the financial side, only one wallet holding around $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, according to the court record; the brothers had moved the rest of the funds by October 2023.

Background

The Peraire-Bueno brothers were indicted in May 2024. Their first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors could not agree on a verdict. The case drew attention because it was the first federal criminal prosecution centered on MEV, a practice in which participants seek profit by influencing the ordering of transactions on a blockchain. Sandwich attacks are among the best-known strategies: a bot spots a large pending purchase, buys the same asset first, and sells once the original order lifts the price.

What to watch

The acquittal may shape how future disputes over MEV, automated trading and liability in decentralized networks are argued, but it does not answer broader questions about the ethics of sandwich attacks or what responsibilities attach to those running blockchain infrastructure. Whether prosecutors can build viable cases on different legal theories remains untested, and the ruling may invite further litigation over conduct that sits outside the fraud statutes as drafted.

Questions readers ask

Why did the wire fraud charge fail?

Judge Clarke found prosecutors did not prove a material misrepresentation that another party relied on. The mempool did not promise a particular execution order, and the relay never used the zeroed header fields, so the false data did not affect its decisions.

Does this ruling make MEV extraction legal?

No. The decision resolves the specific fraud and conspiracy charges against the two brothers. It does not establish that every MEV strategy or exploit is lawful, and the judge noted that questionable conduct is not automatically criminal.

What happened in the earlier trial?

The brothers were indicted in May 2024. A first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict, leading to the November 16 acquittal instead of another trial.

Sources · 2 publishers

  1. Coinpedia TIER 3 FIRST REPORT
    Ethereum MEV Exploit Case Collapses as Judge Acquits Brothers
  2. Bitcoinist TIER 2
    Judge Clears MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case, Citing Lack of Fraud