Strategy faces MSCI review that could spur billions in MSTR selling

What happened

MSCI is set to publish the results of its November index review on Nov. 11, leaving Strategy's place in major equity benchmarks uncertain. The index provider said its final list of additions and deletions would appear shortly after 11 p.m. Central European Time on Wednesday, and any changes would apply after the market closes on Nov. 30. Crypto.news and Coinpedia both reported that the review puts Strategy, the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin, under scrutiny.

The risk comes from eligibility criteria MSCI approved on Oct. 15. The rules are designed to exclude companies whose financial profile looks more like an investment fund than an operating business. MSCI first checks whether a company has substantial operating assets. Companies that do not pass that screen are then measured against five financial tests covering assets, expenses, operating cash flow, fair-value exposure and reliance on external financing. An issuer can become ineligible if it fails at least four of the five tests. Existing constituents must meet the exclusion conditions across their two most recent annual reporting periods, though MSCI can also consider more recent interim filings.

Strategy has acknowledged the risk in its financial disclosures and said it expects its common stock to be removed under the revised criteria, according to Crypto.news. The company's shares have already weakened ahead of the decision. MSTR closed at $121.07 on Nov. 10, down about 16.6% from $145.16 on Oct. 28. Coinpedia reported that the stock fell 3.60% in that session, traded between $118.43 and $126.40 and remained well below its 52-week high of $234.84.

Strategy has continued to buy Bitcoin despite the stock pressure. On Nov. 9, it disclosed the purchase of another 1,036 BTC, bringing holdings to 850,364 BTC as of Nov. 8. It also repurchased about $188.3 million of its STRC preferred shares, using proceeds from common stock sales. The company reported about $4.9 billion in U.S. dollar assets alongside its Bitcoin treasury.

Why it matters

The main channel for market impact is passive investment. Funds that track MSCI benchmarks would need to adjust their portfolios around the Nov. 30 implementation date if Strategy is removed. JPMorgan analysts have estimated that exclusion could produce roughly $2.8 billion in institutional selling, though the estimate was prepared under an earlier version of MSCI's proposed rules. Strategy has said MSCI-tracking funds hold about 13 million MSTR shares, equal to around 3.1% of basic shares outstanding. At Tuesday's closing price, that stake was worth about $1.57 billion. That figure is the market value of estimated index-fund holdings, not a confirmed amount of selling.

An MSCI exclusion would not itself force Strategy to sell Bitcoin. The immediate effect would fall on investment funds holding MSTR shares. Any consequence for Strategy's Bitcoin purchases would depend on future financing decisions. A sustained decline in the share price could make common stock issuance less attractive, particularly if the company's market valuation moves closer to the value of its Bitcoin holdings. Strategy has relied on equity offerings and preferred securities to fund Bitcoin acquisitions.

What the data shows

Coinpedia reported that MSTR's relative strength index stood near 34, approaching oversold territory, and that the data showed a strong sell signal. It identified the $118 to $120 area as an immediate zone to watch and said a recovery above $126 would be an early sign of improving buying interest. Those are market observations, not guarantees of future performance.

Strategy's latest disclosure put its Bitcoin holdings at 850,364 BTC as of Nov. 8, after the 1,036 BTC purchase. The company also reported about $4.9 billion in U.S. dollar assets. JPMorgan's $2.8 billion outflow estimate and Strategy's 13 million-share index exposure figure are the central numbers in the debate over how much passive selling could follow an MSCI removal.

Background

MSCI's new framework, approved on Oct. 15, targets companies whose balance sheets are dominated by investments rather than operating businesses. Strategy's large Bitcoin position has made its business model a focus of that review. The potential exclusions are not limited to Strategy. Japan's Metaplanet and uranium investment firm Yellow Cake have also been identified as companies with investment-heavy balance sheets that could face similar eligibility questions.

Market commentator Adrian Morris argued that much of the potential selling pressure may already be reflected in MSTR's share price. In a Nov. 11 post on X, he said an official exclusion announcement could cause another decline but described the event as likely priced in and not a terminal event for the company, according to Crypto.news. Previous analysis has also raised the possibility of further outflows if other major index providers adopt comparable restrictions.

What to watch

Investors and market observers will watch MSCI's final list on Nov. 11 and the implementation date after the Nov. 30 close. They will also track whether other index providers adopt similar eligibility rules, which could broaden the pressure on companies with investment-heavy balance sheets. For Strategy, the focus remains on its share price, its access to capital markets and whether it continues to fund Bitcoin purchases through stock and preferred offerings.

Questions readers ask