Stablecoins · Explained
S&P keeps USDT at weakest stability score as riskier-asset exposure reaches 28%
S&P Global Ratings kept Tether's USDT at its lowest stability grade after higher-risk assets rose to 28% of circulating tokens, a finding Tether disputes.
Key takeaways
- Risk share. S&P put higher-risk assets at 28% of circulating USDT, up four percentage points from a year earlier.
- Reserve cushion. Tether reported $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, a 104.3% collateralization ratio.
- Disclosure. S&P said KPMG's audited statements and auditor report were not public, while Tether disputes the agency's methodology.
What happened
S&P Global Ratings kept its stability assessment for Tether's USDT at 5, the lowest mark on its five-point scale, in a Nov. 18 review. The score was unchanged from November 2025. The assessment is meant to gauge whether a stablecoin can hold its dollar peg and is not a formal credit rating. Crypto.news and Bitcoin.com News both reported the decision.
The agency's main concern was the reserve mix. It calculated that assets it classes as higher risk were equal to 28% of USDT in circulation at the end of September, compared with 24% a year before. That category includes corporate bonds, secured loans and other holdings exposed to market prices, interest rates and borrower credit quality. S&P warned that a sharp fall in their value could leave USDT undercollateralized.
S&P also noted shifts within Tether's portfolio. Gold holdings rose to about $19 billion from $12.9 billion, public equity investments reached $4.2 billion, and Bitcoin exposure fell to $8.4 billion from $9.9 billion. Despite the weak score, the agency acknowledged that USDT has kept its peg, especially over the prior 12 months. Tether rejected the finding, telling Cointelegraph that the problem was S&P's framework rather than its reserves and invoking the 2008 financial crisis and The Big Short.
First $0.9993Latest $0.99920.0% over the period
Points are daily observations, not closing prices.
Why it matters
USDT is the largest stablecoin, with a market capitalization of about $184 billion at the end of September, and a major source of liquidity in crypto markets. S&P's assessment may shape how issuers, users and counterparties view reserve risk even though it is not a credit rating. The agency said higher-risk assets substantially exceeded Tether's reserve surplus, meaning the buffer may not absorb a large decline. Tether's own figures still showed assets above liabilities.
What the data shows
Tether's third-quarter report, attested by BDO Italia, listed $191.45 billion in assets and $183.50 billion in liabilities, leaving a 104.3% collateralization ratio. The excess reserve cushion was $7.95 billion, up from $4.11 billion at the end of June, according to Crypto.news. Direct and indirect exposure to U.S. Treasury bills was $132.4 billion, and Treasury bills and reverse repurchase agreements generated most operating income. Redemptions are limited to verified customers with at least $100,000 in tokens; the fee schedule lists a $150 verification charge and a redemption fee of $1,000 or 0.1%, whichever is higher. As of Oct. 25, Tron held 50.7% of circulating USDT, Ethereum 46.8% and Solana 1.6%, with those three networks accounting for 99.1%.
Background
S&P lowered USDT from 4 to 5 in November 2025, and Tether's CEO criticized the move at the time. Tether relocated from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025 and now operates under the National Commission of Digital Assets. That regime requires at least $1 in reserves per token and at least 70% in assets liquidatable within 30 days, though S&P considers it less stringent than European and U.S. frameworks because it allows Bitcoin, gold and loans without mandatory segregation. In August, Tether announced that KPMG U.S. had completed its first full independent audit and issued an unqualified opinion on financial statements for 2025; S&P said the statements and auditor's report were not publicly available.
What is still unclear
S&P said public information was insufficient to show how USDT reserves would be protected if Tether became insolvent or faced financial trouble from other ventures, including artificial intelligence and Bitcoin mining. It also said quarterly attestations do not identify custodians, banking partners or counterparties and give too little detail on the credit quality of secured loans and corporate bonds. Tether maintains that non-stablecoin operations are managed separately from USDT reserves.
What to watch
S&P indicated the score could improve if Tether cut higher-risk asset exposure and disclosed more about reserve composition, valuations and counterparty credit quality. The agency's warning centers on a prolonged downturn, when losses on gold, equities, loans or bonds could test the excess cushion. Tether's response and any fuller publication of audited materials are also likely to remain points of contention.
Questions readers ask
What score did USDT receive?
S&P assigned a 5, or weak, on its five-point scale, unchanged from November 2025.
Did Tether accept the assessment?
No. Tether disputed the findings and said S&P's methodology, not its reserves, caused the low score.
Were Tether's assets below its liabilities?
Tether reported $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities as of Sept. 30, a 104.3% collateralization ratio.