Regulation · Explained
SEC nominee Johnson backs public comment for tokenized stock exemption
Kristin Johnson, Trump's Democratic SEC nominee, told senators the agency's tokenized stock trading exemption should go through formal notice-and-comment…
Key takeaways
- Johnson favors formal process. The Democratic nominee said notice-and-comment rulemaking would improve regulation covering tokenized stock trading.
- Exemption terms. The SEC's Sept. 17 order lets qualifying venues trade tokenized versions of listed US shares for five years without exchange registration, with volume and stock-count caps.
- Company objections. At least 67 companies objected to having their shares traded on OKXICE, according to the venue's Nov. 5 public notice.
What happened
Kristin Johnson, President Donald Trump's Democratic nominee to the Securities and Exchange Commission, told senators at a Nov. 19 confirmation hearing that the agency's exemption for tokenized stock trading should be refined through formal rulemaking. Appearing before the Senate Banking Committee, Johnson said she believes regulation benefits from a notice-and-comment process and that she would welcome the chance to address the exemption's issues that way, according to Cointelegraph and Unchained.
The exemption, issued Sept. 17, lets qualifying venues trade blockchain-based versions of US-listed shares without registering as securities exchanges, under certain conditions. It took effect immediately and invited comments on possible changes. Johnson was responding to Sen. Angela Alsobrooks, who has pressed the SEC on the measure.
Johnson, a former Commodity Futures Trading Commission commissioner, appeared alongside Steven Levine, a Republican nominee who is a member of SEC staff and a former aide to Commissioner Mark Uyeda. Levine said he had not closely studied the innovation exemption but understood it to be time-limited and to include investor protections. He said Congress authorized the SEC to grant exemptions when they serve the public interest and remain consistent with investor protection, and he pointed to exchange-traded funds as an innovation that began with exemptive orders before broader rulemaking.
The hearing also touched on compliance concerns. Johnson cited anti-money-laundering and know-your-customer issues, along with objections from industry and lawmakers. Sen. Mark Warner asked how basic AML rules would be enforced for tokenized assets, while Alsobrooks said she and colleagues had sent a letter urging the SEC to reconsider the exemption and criticized its immediate effect without public input.
Why it matters
The hearing highlights the SEC's effort to move from temporary accommodations toward durable rules for digital assets. The agency has scaled back enforcement and pursued changes intended to accommodate crypto, including tokenized securities, while lawmakers and market participants scrutinize the approach. If confirmed, Johnson would be the SEC's only Democratic commissioner and part of a four-member panel with three Republicans and one Democrat. Jessica Martinez, US policy director at Fireblocks, told Cointelegraph that crypto is not a partisan issue and that rules from a bipartisan commission would rest on firmer ground; she also said minority commissioners can influence policy by challenging proposals and pressing unresolved issues before rules are finalized.
What the data shows
At least 67 companies objected to having their shares traded on OKXICE, the joint venture between OKX and NYSE parent Intercontinental Exchange that operates under the innovation exemption, according to the venue's Nov. 5 public notice. The SEC currently has no Democratic commissioners. Senators have until noon Friday to submit additional written questions, with responses due by 5:00 pm ET on Nov. 24, according to the committee's closing remarks. The nominations could then move to a committee vote before the full Senate; both nominees require Senate confirmation.
Background
The SEC issued the innovation exemption on Sept. 17. It permits qualifying venues to trade tokenized versions of listed US stocks onchain for five years without exchange registration, within caps on volume and the number of stocks. A company whose shares are tokenized by an unaffiliated third party gets 30 days to object. SEC Chair Paul Atkins said at the time that the interim measure needed to be followed by durable rulemaking, and the agency sought comment in the order. Jamie Selway, who heads the SEC's Division of Trading and Markets, said on Unchained that the five-year term was designed to keep the agency committed to permanent rulemaking once it could determine what works and what does not. Selway said his comments were his own, not the commission's.
What is still unclear
The reports do not say when the committee will vote or whether the SEC has set a timetable for converting the exemption into a formal rule. They also do not specify how the agency would resolve the companies' objections or what AML and KYC standards would apply to tokenized stock trading under a permanent framework.
What to watch
Senators' written questions and the nominees' responses, due Nov. 24, could clarify their views on the exemption's scope and on AML and KYC safeguards. The committee's next step is a possible vote on the nominations, which would then go to the full Senate. Market participants will also watch whether the SEC opens formal rulemaking and how it handles objections from listed companies.
Questions readers ask
What does the SEC exemption allow?
The Sept. 17 order lets qualifying venues trade blockchain-based versions of US-listed shares without registering as securities exchanges for five years, subject to volume and stock-count limits and a process for companies to object.
Why does Johnson want formal rulemaking?
She said regulation is improved through notice-and-comment and that she would welcome addressing the exemption's issues through that process.
What are the next steps for the nominations?
Senators have until noon Friday to submit written questions, with responses due by 5 p.m. ET on Nov. 24. The nominations could then advance to a committee vote and later be considered by the full Senate.